Window Decision Guide™
← All buyer guides

Before you sign

How to compare replacement-window quotes

The lowest number is only useful when you know what it includes. Put the proposals beside each other and compare the same openings, product details, and work. A difference in scope can explain a difference in price.

Start with the same project

Number each window opening by room and location. Ask both companies to identify which openings are included, the operating style, and any size changes. Count windows the same way: one large opening can contain several window units.

Write down the exact product series, frame material, color, hardware, and glass package. A material name by itself does not identify a complete product.

Ask what comes out and what stays

Have each company explain whether the existing frame stays, what trim is disturbed, and what is included in sealing and finishing. Ask how it will assess existing damage and document any additional work before charging for it.

An insert and a full-frame installation can involve different work. Ask for the reason the company recommends its approach for your particular openings.

Compare performance and service

Ask for the NFRC ratings for the proposed window and glass configuration. ENERGY STAR certification varies by climate zone, so check the product for your location. A rating for another glass package is not the specification of your quote.

Read the product and installation warranties separately. Ask who handles a service call, what labor is covered, what exclusions apply, and whether coverage transfers to another homeowner.

Get the complete price in writing

Request the installed total, taxes, included finishing, cleanup, disposal, and any known exclusions. Compare the actual final price and scope, rather than the size of an advertised discount.

If you plan to borrow, compare the purchase contract and financing agreement separately. A lower monthly payment alone does not tell you the total cost. Ask for the APR, term, fees, and total of payments.

Your quote comparison sheet

Use this during appointments. Mark unclear items and ask the company to put its answer in the proposal.

Compare the same scope from two window companies
What to compareCompany ACompany B
Openings, quantity, and operating styles
Exact product series, material, and finish
Glass package and NFRC ratings
Existing frame: retained or removed?
Damage assessment and extra-work approval
Interior/exterior finishing and cleanup
Product warranty and installation warranty
Installed total, taxes, and exclusions
Schedule, payment milestones, and service contact
Financing APR, fees, term, and total payments

Window Decision Guide · windowdecisionguide.com/learn/compare-window-quotes

Your next step

Put the choices together.

Build a window plan at your own pace, or ask Tanner a question about your project.